You Can Only Write One Genre for the Rest of Your Writerly Life!

As a writer, the last thing I want to do is restrict myself. Yes, it’s true, there are genres that I will never write (erotica, true crime, nonfiction textbooks on astrophysics), but other than that, I’m open to pretty much anything. I love straddling the line between genres, often bridging fantasy, science fiction, and paranormal and then throwing in some literary flair.

So, imagine my surprise when I was told that I should pick and stick to one genre. My conversation went something like this:

Me: “My most recent work is a blend of fantasy and sci-fi, but I have ideas that venture into horror, paranormal, and even contemporary fiction.”

Acquaintance-With-Some-Writing-Experience: “Aren’t you worried?”

Me: “No. Why?”

Acquaintance-With-Some-Writing-Experience: “I learned in my creative writing courses that authors should stick to one genre. That way, they become really good at writing it, and they become specialized in that field.”

I’m not going to lie, I understand the logic, but I was taken aback. First of all, I haven’t taken many courses. I took a few in high school and one in university, but I didn’t major in creative writing (and I didn’t want to, but that’s for another post). Most of what I learned about writing was a trial and error of sorts: reading a lot, writing a lot (of crap, I might add), getting feedback from beta-readers.

But I was completely floored that a creative writing instructor would tell students that they had to pick one genre and only one genre, and any straying was literary suicide.

You must choose ONE pill that will seal your fate for all-- Oh, wrong post.

You must choose ONE pill that will seal your fate for all of — Oh, wrong post.

Needless to say, I disagreed with this conclusion vehemently. I didn’t really say what I was thinking, giving my acquaintance some response between apathy and “to each his own”. There’s nothing wrong with writing only one genre, but there are two fundamental problems with the argument my acquaintance presented. Observe.

Tastes Change

Writers, like all other human beings, are not static. If you had given me a salad 5 years ago, and you happened to put onions in it, I would have picked all of them out, avoiding them like they were hemlock or something. Now, however, I love onions. Put onions in EVERYTHING! I’m not even sorry for my stinky breath.

The same goes for writing. When I was younger, I loved Harry Potter. In fact, I loved it so much that I wanted to write a series about a school that taught the occult arts, and instead of wizards and witches, the students were known as little devils. Luckily, that idea didn’t last long, and as I read more, I grew to want to write more. Even now, I read more widely than ever: fantasy, science fiction, young adult, literary, horror. And ultimately, what kind of writer doesn’t get impacted by what they’re reading?

For me, diversifying is a form of improvement. By changing up what I read, I am exposed to different forms of writing, and trying them out helps me hone my craft. Is everything I produce good? Of course not, but if I’ve written something that I love and that I believe in, why should I deny it its chance to shine because it isn’t in the pre-determined genre I’ve chosen?

The Greats Don’t Always Stick with This Rule

After the Harry Potter series, JK Rowling wrote a contemporary drama and then a series of mystery novels under the name Robert Galbraith. Margaret Atwood is known for bending the rules and writing across genres, often spanning mystery, science fiction, and literary fiction. Do I think I’m on the same level as these greats? Well, no. But they’ve found success in multiple genres, so why can’t I?

Regardless of these two arguments, however, I think this solution to this issue comes down to one thing: where does your inspiration lie? There are many successful writers that stick to a single genre, and they do quite well. There are ALSO successful writers who write across genres. Do I think this has impacts on the quality of the writing itself? No. I think if a writer writes well enough, they can tackle any genre they’re passionate about.

What do you think? Are you a one genre kind of writer, or do you like traversing multiple ones?

Advertisements

8 responses to “You Can Only Write One Genre for the Rest of Your Writerly Life!

  1. This is almost spooky that you wrote on this. I just finished a post myself today on almost the very same topic. I hate being stuck in a box. Cross genre writers prevail!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. While it is true that authors usually stick to one genre, and often true that they are required to do so by publishers and fan base, I don’t think any writer should go into writing thinking they can only ever write one genre. As your career develops, this may happen, but it also might turn out that you have the opportunity to branch out. I guess I think writers should be ready for any change in their careers, because it might be a golden opportunity. As for me, I write YA speculative fiction. I’ll probably stick with that because there’s so much I can do under that umbrella, but if a different story in a different genre strikes my fancy, then I will write what I love!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I share your frustration. Stephen King actually addresses this nonsense in a really direct (and meta) way in the Dark Tower series, but he’s Stephen King, so of course he can break as many rules blend as many genres as he wants and get away with it. I guess what it really comes down to is branding. With so many authors competing for everyone’s attention, you just have a better chance of standing out if your authorly persona can be easily categorized and marketed to a really specific fanbase. Which makes life really hard for those of us whose work just refuses to fit into one of these prefab categories, because the only option we have is to try inventing an entirely new genre and hoping desperately that anyone notices.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I’ve noticed a trend in authors exploring other genres. Most seem to pick a pen name when they shoot off onto those other paths. I used to write humor and had a decent fan base, but I got bored and switched back to speculative fiction (nothing published). I’m planning on doing the whole “pen name” thing. I, too, want to explore horror as well as other genres. I’d get too bored writing in a single genre. *yawn.*

    Like

  5. For once in my life, I agree with everything someone else said–you, in this blog. 🙂

    Like

  6. Oh, and that includes your thoughts on onions…haha

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s